Towing company vs auto transport company, which one is a right option for you? Sometimes a drive in the car is not feasible when your car needs maintenance or you might be moving to another state for a new job promotion.
In these situations, as well as others, you will need assistance moving your vehicle. Car towing and car shipping are the two most commonly used options. While people sometimes confuse towing with auto-hauling, the two activities are different.
Here, our professionals at AutoStar Transport Express discuss the differences and explain whether towing or shipping is best for your situation.
Key Highlights
- Towing companies handle short-distance, emergency situations, while auto transport companies are designed for planned long-distance vehicle moves.
- Towing is generally cheaper for quick, local trips, but auto transport is more cost-effective and convenient for long distances.
- Auto transport reduces wear and tear and offers safer handling, especially for high-value or long-distance shipments.
Need a Tow? Request Immediate Assistance Today!
No upfront payment • No hidden charges • Fully insured transport • A+ BBB Rating
Quick Comparison: Towing vs Auto Transport at a Glance
| Feature | Towing Company | Auto Transport Company |
|---|---|---|
| Best For | Short distances (under 100 miles) | Long distances (100+ miles) |
| Response Time | Same day, 24/7 availability | Scheduled in advance (1-7 days) |
| Cost for Short Distance | More affordable | Not cost-effective |
| Cost for Long Distance | Very expensive | More affordable |
| Vehicle Wear & Tear | High (engine mileage adds up) | Minimal (vehicle doesn't run) |
| Safety | Higher damage risk due to rushing | Lower risk, professional handling |
| Ideal Situations | Breakdowns, emergencies, local moves | State-to-state moves, multiple vehicles |
| Flexibility | Immediate, same-day service | Requires advance planning |
What is a Towing Company?
Towing companies run short distances and respond immediately, unlike auto transport companies. The reason is usually an emergency. Towing is the best choice when your car breaks down and you need immediate assistance.
Despite providing fast service, the cost may be higher than an auto transport company. Since most towing companies operate 24 hours a day, they are ideal for moving vehicles both during the day and at night. Depending on the towing company, they may have wheel lift tow trucks or flatbed tow trucks for moving vehicles.
There is a greater chance that a towing company can cause damage because the drivers rush from one job to the next. Because towing is often time-sensitive, it can involve faster turnaround and higher operational pressure.
A towing company also offers roadside services such as tire changes, jump starts, fuel delivery, and ditch recovery. Apart from that, they are often hired by companies to remove illegally parked vehicles from parking lots or by local governments to recover repossessed vehicles. They are therefore limited by distance, usually less than 100 miles.
Related Article: Is AAA the Best Option for Long-Distance Towing?
The Benefits of Hiring a Towing Company
- Towing companies typically offer 24/7 service. So when you call, they’ll come on the same day. When you are in a hurry or don’t want to wait, the towing company is the answer.
- A towing company has another advantage over car shipping, which is flexibility. It is necessary to schedule car shipping in advance. Towing is typically scheduled on the same day.
- There is no better way to move broken-down cars across town.
Ship Your Car with our Door-to-Door Transport Service Now!
No upfront payment • No hidden charges • Fully insured transport • A+ BBB Rating
Car Towing Cons
- Towing your car comes with several risks. Firstly, the risks of long distance towing with your trailer. In a perfect world, nothing would go wrong, but user error is still possible. You have to assume the risks if you are going the DIY route. In addition, towing puts wear and tear on your engine. In all cases, towing will wear down a towing vehicle. You can’t control all the factors that impact wear and tear.
- Towing is always the most affordable option for short distances. In case you own a car capable of towing and you rent only a trailer (or you own a trailer), that configuration may be the most economical option – but at an added cost of time and energy.
When to Tow Your Car?
Do you wonder whether it is necessary to tow your car? Towing is generally a good option for short distances. It is a cheaper option to tow your vehicle for long-distance travel if only a trailer is rented. Often, car shipping is the cheaper and safer option – as well as being more useful and efficient – than renting both a towing vehicle and a trailer.
What You Can Expect from the Tow Truck Driver
A tow truck driver will attach the front bumper of a stalled vehicle to a hook and then secure it with chains. Occasionally, a towing company will send drivers to pick up vehicles on flatbeds. The driver would then load the stalled vehicle onto the flatbed truck, secure it with chains, and ensure that the truck was secured in the back.
Trust Us for All Your Auto Shipping Needs
What is an Auto Transport Company?
In contrast to a towing company, an auto transport company carries vehicles longer distances and can be used in a planned manner, even when going down the street.
Auto transport is known by many names but it all means the same thing. Car transport, car shipping, vehicle transport, vehicle shipping, and auto transport are just a few of the terms used interchangeably. It is important to understand that long-distance towing always refers to auto transport.
Auto transport is all about saving money. Every vehicle on a 10-car carrier that is going somewhere will split the cost of a shipment and the cost of transporting the vehicles.
Using an auto transport company will help prevent your car from getting damaged since they’re using a carrier or flatbed to transport your car, and they aren’t rushing around the city to transport as many cars as they can within the allotted time.
Deliver Your Car Anywhere in the USA with Our Car Delivery Service!
No upfront payment • No hidden charges • Fully insured transport • A+ BBB Rating
The Benefits of Hiring an Auto Transport Company
- Your car shipping company only needs to know the first date your vehicle is available to the next carrier in your direction. The only physical effort you need to put in is driving to the pickup or drop-off location.
- Towing your car yourself means driving for hours or even days. The driving is done by someone else when shipping a car. If you’re moving states, you can ship your car and fly or drive there faster without hauling another vehicle. Most carriers serve all 48 states in the continental United States.
- Towing your car is often more expensive than shipping it. Trailers (and vehicles) can be expensive to rent, not to mention gas mileage and repair costs afterward. Towing your car across state lines is almost unheard of, and will cost you much more than getting it shipped by an auto transport company.
Ship Your Car Across Country With Ease
Car Shipping: Cons
- Shipping cars often involves more than one car. Occasionally, there are delays because other cars must be picked up and dropped off.
- There are fewer car shipping companies than towing companies or car rental agencies. Having fewer options can make finding the right fit more difficult, especially if you have special requests or a demanding schedule. That is why AutoStar Transport Express is such a reputable broker.
- The scheduling and cost of shipping a car are usually not worthwhile for short trips within 50 miles. In these cases, a towing service will provide faster and more affordable transportation.
When to Choose Car Shipping
Traveling a long-distance? The best choice for you is car shipping. A car shipping company’s prices are typically low since they ship multiple vehicles simultaneously.
Transport your Car with Ease with an Automobile Transport Services
No upfront payment • No hidden charges • Fully insured transport • A+ BBB Rating
Cost Breakdown: Towing vs Auto Transport
Understanding the real cost difference can help you make an informed decision. Here’s what impacts pricing for each service:
Towing Cost Factors
- Distance: Typically $75-$125 for the first 5-10 miles, then $2-$4 per additional mile
- Time of service: After-hours and weekend rates can be 50% higher
- Vehicle type: Larger vehicles or those requiring specialized equipment cost more
- Hookup fees: Usually $35-$100 just to attach your vehicle
- Storage fees: If your car stays at the tow yard ($20-$50 per day)
Example: Towing 500 miles could cost $1,000-$2,000 or more, plus significant wear on your vehicle.
Auto Transport Cost Factors
- Distance: Average $0.60-$1.00 per mile for distances over 500 miles
- Route popularity: Common routes (like California to Texas) cost less
- Vehicle size and weight: Larger vehicles occupy more carrier space
- Transport type: Open carrier vs enclosed transport
- Season: Summer months (peak moving season) may cost 10-30% more
- Condition: Non-running vehicles cost $150-$300 extra
Example: Shipping 500 miles typically costs $400-$600, and your vehicle arrives without added mileage.
The Break-Even Point
For distances under 100 miles, towing is usually more economical. Between 100-200 miles, costs become comparable. Beyond 200 miles, auto transport becomes significantly cheaper and safer for your vehicle.
8 Common Scenarios: Which Service Should You Choose?
Scenario 1: Emergency Breakdown on Highway
- Best Choice: Towing Company
- Why: Immediate response needed, likely short distance to nearest mechanic
Scenario 2: Moving Across Country for New Job
- Best Choice: Auto Transport Company
- Why: Long distance makes auto transport more affordable and convenient; you can fly instead of driving
Scenario 3: Buying a Car From Another State
- Best Choice: Auto Transport Company
- Why: Safe delivery without adding mileage to your new purchase
Scenario 4: Car Won’t Start in Your Driveway
- Best Choice: Towing Company
- Why: Quick local transport to your trusted mechanic
Scenario 5: Snowbird Moving Vehicle Seasonally
- Best Choice: Auto Transport Company
- Why: Regular long-distance moves benefit from planned shipping at lower rates
Scenario 6: College Student Moving Home for Summer
- Best Choice: Depends on Distance
- Why: Under 200 miles, consider towing; over 200 miles, ship it and save time
Scenario 7: Classic or Luxury Car to Auto Show
- Best Choice: Auto Transport (Enclosed)
- Why: Maximum protection for high-value vehicles, no mileage added
Scenario 8: Accident Recovery Within City
- Best Choice: Towing Company
- Why: Insurance often covers towing, need immediate removal from accident scene
How to Choose the Right Service Provider
Questions to Ask a Towing Company
- Are you available 24/7?
- What’s your average response time to my location?
- Do you have flatbed trucks available?
- What’s included in your base rate vs additional charges?
- Are you licensed and insured?
- Do you offer roadside assistance services?
- What’s your policy if damage occurs during towing?
Questions to Ask an Auto Transport Company
- Are you a broker or a carrier? (Or both?)
- What insurance coverage do you provide?
- Can I track my vehicle during transport?
- What’s your estimated pickup and delivery window?
- Do you offer both open and enclosed transport?
- What’s your cancellation policy?
- How do you handle vehicle inspections?
- Are you registered with the FMCSA and have a valid MC number?
- What payment methods do you accept?
- Do you require a deposit, and is it refundable?
Preparing Your Vehicle: A Step-by-Step Checklist
Before Towing
- Remove all personal belongings from the vehicle
- Disable car alarm to prevent it activating during transport
- Document existing damage with photos
- Note fuel level (should be under 1/4 tank)
- Secure or remove loose parts (antennas, spoilers)
- Inform the driver of any vehicle-specific issues
- Get written estimate before service begins
Before Auto Transport
- Wash your car thoroughly (makes inspection easier)
- Document all existing damage with dated photos
- Remove or secure custom accessories
- Remove toll tags and parking passes
- Check for fluid leaks and mechanical issues
- Leave fuel tank at 1/4 full or less (safety requirement)
- Disable alarm systems completely
- Leave only one set of keys with the driver
- Remove all personal items (insurance won’t cover these)
- Check tire pressure and ensure proper inflation
- Lock the glove box if leaving registration inside
Red Flags to Watch Out For
Towing Company Warning Signs
- No physical address or local phone number
- Demanding cash-only payments
- Refusing to provide insurance information
- Extremely low quotes compared to competitors
- Unprofessional or aggressive behavior
- No visible company identification on trucks
Auto Transport Company Warning Signs
- Requiring large deposits upfront (over $100-200 is suspicious)
- No MC (Motor Carrier) number or USDOT number
- Quotes that seem too good to be true (likely will increase later)
- Pressure to sign contracts immediately
- No physical address or always unavailable
- Unwilling to provide insurance certificates
- Poor or no online reviews
- Refusing to answer specific questions about their service
Conclusion
Choosing between towing and auto transport depends on distance and urgency. Towing is best for short-distance emergencies with quick, 24/7 service, while auto transport is ideal for planned long-distance moves. It’s safer, more convenient, and often more cost-effective beyond 100–200 miles. Assess your needs: use a tow truck for local breakdowns and a car shipping company for stress-free long trips. Your vehicle, wallet, and peace of mind will benefit.
Get Your Instant Vehicle Transport Quote Now!
No upfront payment • No hidden charges • Fully insured transport • A+ BBB Rating
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I put items inside my car during auto transport?
Most carriers allow up to 100 lbs in the trunk, but items aren’t insured. Never leave valuables.
How far in advance should I book auto transport?
2-4 weeks is ideal for domestic shipping. Peak season (May-September) may require more lead time.
Will my insurance cover damage during towing?
Usually yes, if you have comprehensive coverage. Check your policy and document everything.
Can a towing company transport my car across states?
Technically yes, but it’s extremely expensive and impractical. Use auto transport for interstate moves.
What if my car doesn’t run?
Towing companies handle non-running vehicles regularly. Auto transport companies can too, but charge $150-300 extra.
Is enclosed transport worth the extra cost?
For luxury, classic, or exotic vehicles worth over $50,000, yes. For standard vehicles, open transport is safe and economical.
How long does auto transport take?
Average 1-2 days per 500 miles, but pickup windows and multi-vehicle routes can extend this to 1-2 weeks for cross-country transport.
Can I track my vehicle during auto transport?
Most reputable companies offer tracking or regular updates. Ask about this when booking.
