Open or Enclosed Car Shipping? Discover the Key Differences

When choosing between the cost-effectiveness of open and the protection of enclosed auto transport, it’s crucial to evaluate your options carefully. Shipping your vehicle across the country involves deciding between open and enclosed car shipping methods, each offering distinct advantages and considerations. To help you make the best choice, AutoStar Transport Express provides both services, tailored to your specific requirements. This article delves into the differences between open and enclosed car shipping, highlighting how AutoStar Transport Express can guide you to the optimal solution for your needs.

Open vs Enclosed Car Shipping: Quick Comparison

Open vs Enclosed Auto Transport Cost Breakdown

Open vs Enclosed Auto Transport: Detailed Cost Analysis

Understanding the cost difference between open and enclosed auto transport helps you make an informed decision. Here’s what you need to know about pricing:

Open Car Shipping Costs:

• Short distance (0-500 miles): $300 – $600
• Medium distance (500-1,500 miles): $600 – $900
• Cross-country (1,500+ miles): $800 – $1,200
• Cost per mile typically decreases with distance

Enclosed Car Shipping Costs:

• Short distance (0-500 miles): $450 – $850
• Medium distance (500-1,500 miles): $900 – $1,350
• Cross-country (1,500+ miles): $1,200 – $1,800
• Premium increases 30-60% over open transport

Factors Affecting Both Methods:

• Vehicle size and weight (larger vehicles cost more)
• Pickup and delivery locations (rural areas increase cost)
• Seasonal demand (summer months are peak season)
• Vehicle condition (non-running vehicles cost 25-50% more)
• Expedited shipping (rush delivery adds $200-500)
• Door-to-door vs terminal-to-terminal service

Is Enclosed Car Shipping Worth the Extra Cost?

Enclosed transport is worth the premium if your vehicle:

• Has a value exceeding $50,000
• Is a classic or vintage automobile
• Requires protection for car shows or auctions
• Features custom paint, modifications, or wraps
• Holds significant sentimental value
• Is an exotic or luxury brand (Ferrari, Lamborghini, Bentley, etc.)

For everyday vehicles under $30,000, open transport provides excellent value without unnecessary expense.

Open Car Shipping

1. Design and Structure:

• Trailer Type: Open car shipping utilizes open-air trailers, which can be flatbeds or multi-car carriers. These trailers have no sides or roof, allowing for easy loading and unloading of vehicles.
• Loading: Vehicles are driven onto the trailer using ramps, and then secured with tie-down straps or chains to prevent movement during transit.

2. Exposure and Protection:

• Environmental Exposure: Unlike enclosed trailers, open carriers expose vehicles to the elements. This includes potential exposure to rain, snow, dust, road debris, and sunlight.
• Security: Vehicles are generally safe from theft due to secure strapping and the low-profile nature of the carriers, though they are still exposed to some risk of minor damage from environmental factors.

3. Cost Efficiency:

• Affordability: Open car shipping is typically less expensive than enclosed car shipping. The open design allows carriers to transport multiple vehicles simultaneously, which spreads the cost among several customers.
• Cost Factors: Factors influencing the cost include distance, the size and weight of the vehicle, and the current demand for shipping services.

4. Scheduling and Availability:

• Wide Availability: Open car shipping is more common and has a broader network of carriers, making it easier to find available services and schedule shipments.
• Flexibility: Due to the high number of open carriers, scheduling is often more flexible, and you may find quicker turnaround times compared to enclosed shipping.

5. Ideal Use Cases:

• Standard Vehicles: Open car shipping is well-suited for standard vehicles and everyday cars that do not require specialized protection.
• Budget-Conscious Shipping: For those looking to minimize costs without needing the added protection of an enclosed trailer, open car shipping is a practical choice.

6. Common Applications:

• Relocations: Ideal for moving vehicles during residential or commercial relocations.
• Long-Distance Transport: Often used for long-distance car transport, such as from one state to another, due to its affordability and availability.

Effortlessly Move Your Car Across the Country

Get Started

Advantages and Disadvantages of Open Car Shipping

Advantages:

• Cost-Effective: Open car shipping is generally less expensive compared to enclosed car shipping. The open design allows for the transportation of multiple vehicles simultaneously, which reduces the cost per vehicle. This is ideal for those on a budget or shipping multiple vehicles.
• Wide Availability: Open car shipping is more common and widely available due to the large number of open trailers and carriers. This makes it easier to find available carriers and schedule shipments, often with more flexible timing.
• Efficient Loading and Unloading: The open design of the trailer makes it easier to load and unload vehicles, simplifying the process of vehicle handling and reducing potential delays.
• Faster Transit Times: With a higher number of carriers available, open car shipping can offer quicker transit times, especially if the carrier is part of a large fleet.

Disadvantages:

• Exposure to the Elements: Vehicles are exposed to weather conditions like rain, snow, and sunlight, as well as road debris. This increased exposure can lead to minor damage such as scratches or dings from environmental factors.
• Less Security: While vehicles are secured with straps, they are more exposed to theft or vandalism compared to enclosed options. This higher potential for theft or vandalism can be a concern, particularly in areas with higher crime rates.
• Limited Protection: Open trailers do not offer protection from environmental factors, which can be a concern for luxury, classic, or high-value vehicles. These vehicles may require higher levels of protection due to their value or condition.
• Increased Exposure to Road Debris: Vehicles on open trailers are exposed to road debris kicked up by other vehicles, which can lead to additional wear and tear or minor damage from road hazards.

Enclosed Car Shipping

Enclosed car shipping involves transporting vehicles inside a fully covered trailer, providing enhanced protection during transit. Here’s an overview of enclosed car shipping:

Design and Structure:

• Trailer Type: Enclosed car shipping uses trailers with walls and a roof, completely covering the vehicle. These trailers come in various sizes, including single-car and multi-car options.
• Loading: Vehicles are carefully loaded into the trailer, often using hydraulic lifts or ramps. The interior is designed to ensure that the vehicle is securely fastened and protected from movement during transit.

Protection and Security:

• Environmental Protection: The enclosed design shields vehicles from weather elements such as rain, snow, sunlight, and road debris. This reduces the risk of damage from external factors and helps maintain the vehicle’s condition.
• Security: The enclosed nature of the trailer provides a higher level of security against theft and vandalism. Vehicles are less visible and more secure within the trailer, offering peace of mind during transport.

Cost and Availability:

• Cost: Enclosed car shipping is generally more expensive than open car shipping due to the added protection and specialized equipment. Costs can vary based on distance, vehicle size, and additional services.
• Availability: While not as common as open car shipping, enclosed car shipping is available through specialized transport companies. Scheduling might be less flexible, and availability may vary based on location and demand.

Ideal Use Cases:

• High-Value and Classic Vehicles: Enclosed car shipping is ideal for luxury, classic, or high-value vehicles that require extra care and protection. The enclosed trailer provides a safe environment, reducing the risk of potential damage or wear.
• Temperature-Sensitive Vehicles: Some enclosed trailers offer climate control features, making them suitable for vehicles sensitive to temperature changes, such as classic cars or those with delicate interiors.

Common Applications:

• Luxury and Collectible Cars: Often used for transporting high-end or collectible vehicles that demand the highest level of care.
• Long-Distance Moves: Suitable for long-distance car transport where maintaining the vehicle’s condition is a priority.

Advantages and Disadvantages of Enclosed Car Shipping

Benefits of Enclosed Car Shipping

Choosing enclosed auto transport offers numerous advantages for high-value vehicles. Here are the key benefits:

1. Complete Weather Protection Enclosed car carriers shield your vehicle from rain, snow, hail, sleet, and extreme temperatures. Unlike open transport, your car arrives in the exact condition it left, regardless of weather conditions during transit.
2. Protection from Road Debris Highway travel exposes vehicles to rocks, gravel, tar, and debris from other vehicles. Enclosed trailers eliminate this risk, protecting your paint, windshield, and exterior finish.
3. Enhanced Security and Privacy Your vehicle remains hidden from view during transport, providing additional security and discretion. This is particularly valuable for rare collectibles or high-profile vehicle shipments.
4. Reduced UV and Sun Damage Direct sunlight during multi-day transport can fade interiors and damage paint finishes. Enclosed carriers protect against harmful UV rays throughout the journey.
5. Lower Insurance Risk The reduced exposure to potential damage often results in lower insurance claims, making it ideal for vehicles where even minor cosmetic damage would be costly to repair.
6. Specialized Handling Enclosed auto carriers typically transport fewer vehicles (2-6 vs 7-10), allowing for more careful handling and attention to each automobile.
7. Peace of Mind For classic car collectors, luxury vehicle owners, and those transporting vehicles to shows or auctions, enclosed shipping provides invaluable peace of mind knowing your investment is maximally protected.
8. Protection During Long-Distance Moves Cross-country shipments lasting 7-10 days expose vehicles to varying weather conditions across multiple states. Enclosed transport maintains consistent protection throughout.

When Enclosed Vehicle Shipping Makes Sense:

• Classic cars valued over $50,000
• Exotic and luxury vehicles
• Show cars and competition vehicles
• Vehicles with custom paint or modifications
• Antique automobiles requiring preservation
• High-value motorcycles and specialty vehicles

Disadvantages of Enclosed Car Shipping

• Higher Cost: Enclosed car shipping generally costs more than open car shipping due to the added protection and specialized equipment. This may be a concern for those with a tight budget or for standard vehicles where high protection is not a priority.
• Limited Availability: Enclosed car shipping is less common than open car shipping, which might affect availability and scheduling. Finding a carrier and coordinating pickup and delivery may be less flexible and more challenging.
• Potentially Longer Transit Time: Enclosed car shipping might take longer depending on the carrier and route, due to specialized handling and fewer available carriers. This could be an issue for those requiring faster delivery.
• Size and Weight Limitations: Enclosed trailers, particularly single-car units, may have limitations on size and weight. Larger or heavier vehicles may face restrictions or require specialized trailers, potentially increasing costs.

Types of Open and Enclosed Car Shipping

Types of Open Car Shipping

• Open-Air Carrier: Vehicles are transported on an open trailer with no roof or sides. It’s a cost-effective option for standard vehicles and long distances.
• Single-Level Open Trailer: A flatbed trailer carrying one or two vehicles, offering easier access for loading and unloading, suited for short distances.
• Multi-Level Open Trailer: A trailer with stacked levels, allowing multiple vehicles to be transported simultaneously, ideal for high-volume shipping.

Types of Enclosed Car Shipping

• Single-Car Enclosed Trailer: Transports one vehicle in a fully enclosed trailer, providing maximum protection and security, ideal for luxury or classic cars.
• Multi-Car Enclosed Trailer: Accommodates several vehicles in a single enclosed trailer, offering protection for multiple high-value vehicles.
• Climate-Controlled Enclosed Trailer: Features temperature and humidity control, perfect for vehicles sensitive to environmental changes.
• Liftgate Enclosed Trailer: Equipped with a liftgate for easy loading and unloading of low-clearance vehicles or those needing special handling.

Find Out How to Transport Your Vehicle Safely

Explore More

Difference Between Open and Enclosed Car Shipping

Exposure and Protection:

• Open Car Shipping: Vehicles are transported on open trailers with no roof or sides, exposing them to weather conditions, road debris, and potential damage from the elements.
• Enclosed Car Shipping: Vehicles are transported in fully enclosed trailers, shielding them from weather, debris, and environmental factors, offering superior protection.

Security:

• Open Car Shipping: Lower security as vehicles are visible and accessible from outside, increasing the risk of theft and vandalism.
• Enclosed Car Shipping: Higher security with vehicles hidden from view and securely locked inside the trailer, reducing theft and vandalism risks.

Cost:

• Open Car Shipping: Generally more affordable due to the lower cost of the open trailers and less specialized handling.
• Enclosed Car Shipping: More expensive because of the added protection, specialized equipment, and care required.

Handling:

• Open Car Shipping: Typically involves less careful handling, as the focus is on efficiency and cost. Vehicles may be subjected to exposure during loading and unloading.
• Enclosed Car Shipping: Includes meticulous handling and care, with the vehicle protected from environmental exposure and potential damage during transport.

Suitability:

• Open Car Shipping: Ideal for standard vehicles, non-luxury cars, and those where cost is a primary concern.
• Enclosed Car Shipping: Best for high-value, luxury, classic, or delicate vehicles that require extra protection and careful handling.

Open Auto Carrier vs Enclosed Auto Carriers: A Detailed Look

Understanding Open Auto Carriers and Enclosed Auto Carriers

Open Auto Carrier Features:

Open car carriers are the workhorses of the auto transport industry, moving approximately 90% of all vehicles shipped in the United States.

Carrier Types:

• Two-level open trailers (most common): Transport 7-10 vehicles
• Single-level flatbed trailers: Handle larger vehicles or equipment
• Multi-car haulers: Used by dealerships for new inventory

Loading Process: Vehicles are driven onto the carrier using hydraulic ramps, then secured with heavy-duty straps and wheel chocks to prevent movement during transit.

Safety Features:

• Professional-grade tie-down systems
• Hydraulic lift systems for controlled loading
• Experienced drivers trained in vehicle securing
• Regular DOT safety inspections

Enclosed Auto Carriers Features:

Enclosed carriers provide premium protection using fully enclosed trailers with solid walls, roof, and floor.

Carrier Types:

• Hard-sided enclosed trailers: Most common, metal walls
• Soft-sided enclosed trailers: Canvas sides, lower cost
• Multi-level enclosed carriers: Transport 4-6 vehicles
• Single-car enclosed trailers: Ultimate protection

Advanced Protection:

• Climate-controlled options available
• Hydraulic lift gates for low-clearance vehicles
• Padded interiors to prevent contact damage
• Air-ride suspension systems for smooth transport

Which Enclosed Auto Carriers Are Best?

Hard-sided enclosed carriers with climate control offer maximum protection but cost more. Soft-sided enclosed carriers provide excellent protection at a lower price point, suitable for most enclosed shipping needs.

Conclusion

Choosing between open and enclosed car shipping hinges on your vehicle’s value and protection needs. Open car shipping is cost-effective and readily available, ideal for standard vehicles, though it exposes cars to the elements and offers less security. Enclosed car shipping, while pricier and less flexible, provides superior protection and security, making it the best choice for high-value or classic cars. Assess your priorities to select the option that best suits your requirements.
Still unsure? Find out which shipping option is best for your car before you decide.

Streamline Your Car Transport Process

Discover How



Mark Dugger

Born and raised in Southern California, grew up in an athletic environment where he excelled at football, baseball, wrestling, golf, skiing, and water skiing. He chose computers as his professional calling, accepting the position of Systems Officer for a prominent cruise line. For the next ten years, he would circle the globe multiple times, visiting over 100 countries. Mark joined AutoStar Transport Express just 1 year after it was created. He is one of the pillars the company was built on. He started off as a coordinator, he excelled though the years with his hard work and dedication. His job performance not only grew his career but our company and as a whole. Mark now holds the position of operations manager overseeing the engine that makes our company run.

View all posts